“They” quiz
By Siegfried Sassoon
A Bishop's lofty war rhetoric meets the blunt, devastating reality of returning soldiers
11 questions · about 12 minutes
Questions and answers
-
Question 1. Which literary mode best describes "They"?
- Correct answer: Satire
- Elegy
- Epic Poetry
- Pastoral Poetry
- Ode
Satire is correct: Sassoon uses irony and ridicule to attack the Bishop's glorification of war, exposing the absurdity of his platitudes against the soldiers' brutal reality.
Read the passage -
Question 2. Who is the Bishop, and what role does he play in the poem?
- A military commander briefing troops before their deployment to the front lines
- Correct answer: A religious authority glorifying war as a noble crusade against evil forces
- A grieving father trying to make sense of his son's death on the battlefield
- A government official reading casualty reports to an audience of civilians
The Bishop is a religious authority figure who frames the war as a righteous crusade against "Anti-Christ," promising that soldiers will return spiritually ennobled. He represents the civilian establishment that glorifies war from a safe distance.
Read the passage -
Question 3. What is ironic about both the Bishop and the soldiers saying they "will not be the same"?
- Both the Bishop and the soldiers celebrate the spiritual transformation that combat brings
- The soldiers politely correct the Bishop's minor factual errors about conditions at the front
- Correct answer: The Bishop means spiritually ennobled while the soldiers mean physically destroyed and maimed
- The phrase highlights the soldiers' gratitude for the Bishop's moral support during wartime
The Bishop uses "not be the same" to mean spiritually elevated by noble sacrifice. The soldiers echo the phrase but mean something brutally different — they are not the same because they have lost legs, eyesight, and health. The identical words carry opposite meanings.
Read the passage -
Question 4. Which soldier's injury was considered so shocking that the poem was nearly censored?
- George, who lost his hearing from artillery fire
- Jim, who suffered a bayonet wound to his arm
- Bill, who was blinded by poison gas in the trenches
- Correct answer: Bert, who contracted syphilis during his service
Bert's syphilis was considered the most scandalous detail. Mentioning a venereal disease in a poem about soldiers was deeply taboo in 1917 and challenged the idealized image of pure, noble warriors. Sassoon included it deliberately to shatter romanticized views of military service.
Read the passage -
Question 5. What is the central theme of "They"?
- Correct answer: The dangerous gap between patriotic propaganda and the brutal reality of war
- The healing power of religious faith for soldiers suffering from combat wounds
- The importance of military discipline in maintaining troop morale during wartime
- The bond of brotherhood that forms among soldiers who share the battlefield
The poem's central theme is the chasm between the glorified, abstract view of war promoted by authorities like the Bishop and the devastating physical reality endured by soldiers. The Bishop's rhetoric is exposed as dangerously disconnected from truth.
Read the passage -
Question 6. What does the poem suggest about the role of the Church during World War I?
- The Church offered essential medical care and spiritual counseling to wounded soldiers
- Religious leaders were the only voices of compassion advocating for an early peace
- Bishops personally visited the trenches to understand what soldiers endured in combat
- Correct answer: The Church lent its moral authority to war propaganda, framing slaughter as holy duty
By making a Bishop the mouthpiece for war glorification, Sassoon indicts the Church for using its spiritual authority to sanctify the war as a crusade. The Bishop frames killing as fighting "Anti-Christ" and dying as breeding "an honourable race" — holy language masking mass slaughter.
Read the passage -
Question 7. What does "Anti-Christ" mean in this story?
- A political leader who opposes democratic governance and civil liberties
- Correct answer: The supreme enemy of Christ, representing ultimate evil in Christian theology
- A military term for the opposing army's commanding general or leadership
- A historical title for rulers who refused to ally with the Church
The Bishop calls the enemy "Anti-Christ" to cast the war as a holy crusade — a battle between good and evil. This religious framing is precisely what Sassoon is attacking: it transforms a political conflict into a sacred duty, making any questioning of the war seem like blasphemy.
Read the passage -
Question 8. How does the Bishop respond to the soldiers' catalogue of injuries?
- He acknowledges his error and promises to advocate for better care for the wounded
- He doubles down on his message by quoting additional scripture about noble sacrifice
- Correct answer: He retreats into a meaningless cliche that avoids engaging with the soldiers' suffering
- He is moved to tears and vows to visit the hospitals to witness their injuries himself
The Bishop's final line — "The ways of God are strange!" — is a feeble retreat into religious platitude. Rather than confronting the reality of what the soldiers have endured, he dismisses their suffering with a vague appeal to divine mystery, revealing his complete inability (or unwillingness) to engage with the truth.
Read the passage -
Question 9. What is the rhyme scheme and structure of "They"?
- Heroic couplets with alternating speakers in each couplet
- Free verse with no regular rhyme scheme or metrical pattern
- Correct answer: An ABABCC rhyme scheme in two six-line stanzas of iambic pentameter
- A Shakespearean sonnet form with three quatrains and a closing couplet
The poem uses two six-line stanzas with an ABABCC rhyme scheme. The first stanza belongs to the Bishop; the second gives the soldiers' reply (with the Bishop's weak closing line). The formal, orderly structure contrasts sharply with the chaotic reality of the injuries described.
Read the passage -
Question 10. Which literary device best describes the Bishop's shift from grand rhetoric to "The ways of God are strange!"?
- Hyperbole — the Bishop wildly exaggerates the soldiers' heroism for dramatic effect
- Correct answer: Bathos — the Bishop's lofty rhetoric collapses into a feeble, anticlimactic cliche
- Allegory — the Bishop and soldiers represent abstract concepts of good versus evil
- Anaphora — the repeated use of "They" at the start of lines builds rhetorical momentum
Bathos is a sudden, jarring descent from the elevated to the trivial or absurd. The Bishop begins with soaring language about crusades and honourable races, then crumbles into a weak, meaningless platitude when confronted with reality. Sassoon engineers this collapse to maximize the satirical impact.
Read the passage -
Question 11. Which of these events actually happened in the story?
-
The Bishop describes the war as a fight against Anti-Christ.
Happened
The Bishop frames the enemy as Anti-Christ, casting the war as a holy crusade to justify the bloodshed.
-
The soldiers express gratitude for the Bishop's spiritual encouragement.
Didn't happen
The soldiers never express gratitude. They sarcastically echo the Bishop's words and counter with a devastating list of real injuries.
-
George lost both of his legs in the war.
Happened
George is the first soldier named, and his double amputation is the first concrete injury that shatters the Bishop's abstract rhetoric.
-
Bill was injured but recovered his sight after returning home.
Didn't happen
Bill is described as "stone blind" — completely and permanently blind. There is no suggestion of recovery.
-
Jim is shot through the lungs and likely to die.
Happened
Jim's wound is described as fatal — "shot through the lungs and like to die" — making his case the most severe of the named soldiers.
-
The Bishop revises his views after hearing the soldiers' injuries.
Didn't happen
The Bishop does not revise anything. He retreats into "The ways of God are strange!" — a deflection, not a reconsideration.
-
Bert contracted syphilis during his military service.
Happened
Bert's syphilis is the most taboo injury listed, deliberately included by Sassoon to demolish the image of soldiers as pure, noble crusaders.
-
The poem takes place in the trenches of the Western Front.
Didn't happen
The poem is set at home, not in the trenches. The Bishop speaks to or about returning soldiers — the disconnect between home front and battlefield is the entire point.
-
Play it live with your class.
Put the code on the screen and students join on whatever they have.